Ethics II – ST3423: The Doctrine of Vocation                                             Marc Kolden Spring 2008                                                                    Instructor

 

Course Description:  

A study of Christian understandings of vocation, esp. in the theology of the Protestant reformers and in the twentieth century.  The relations of vocation to the distinctions between God’s creative and redemptive work, law and gospel, justification and sanctification, and the two kingdoms concept are considered in working out the implications of vocation for Christian ethics.  Half-course.

 

This course meets on Mondays from 2:10 – 5:00 p.m. in BH 116.

 

 

Objectives:

 

·        To understand the idea of vocation as the Christian’s divine calling in the world as this was articulated by the sixteenth-century reformers, esp. Luther and Calvin.

 

·        To understand the ethics of vocation that developed from the above.

 

·        To learn about some of the history of the idea of Christian vocation and its ethical implications both prior to and especially since the 16th century reformation.

 

·        To become familiar with some of the 20th century thinking on this topic.

 

·        To achieve an informed critical perspective in thinking about vocation.

 

·        To construct a theological an ethical position on Christian vocation and vocational ethics in response to the above.

 

·        To think about one’s own calling(s) from God for service in the world.

 

·        To relate one’s prayer life to one’s calling(s).

 

 

Means of addressing the objectives:

 

  • Required and selected readings           (most important; read for date assigned)

 

·        Class presentations and discussions                 (attendance at all sessions is expected)

 

·        Writing assignments/exams

 

 

Required Reading:  (Buy these three books.)

 

            Gustaf Wingren, Luther on Vocation                                      

 

            Douglas Schuurman, Vocation                                     

 

            Marc Kolden, The Christian’s Calling in the Word               

 

 

Recommended:         

 

Marc Kolden, pamphlets/papers/articles on vocation                 (handouts & reserve)

                        See his homepage: www.luthersem.edu/mkolden/

 

            J. O. Nelson, ed., Work and Vocation; chapter by Calhoun

on “Work and Vocation in Christian History”    (on desk reserve)

 

            Lee Hardy, The Fabric of This World, chapters 2-3                (on desk reserve)

                       

Paul Ramsey, Basic Christian Ethics,  chapter 5                     (on e-reserve)

                       

            Robert Benne, Ordinary Saints (2nd ed.)                                  (on desk reserve)

                       

            George Forell, Faith Active in Love, chapters V-VI                (in library stacks)

                       

            Jean Larson Hurd, A Spirituality of Vocation  (M.Th. thesis)   (on desk reserve)

                       

AND

           

Martin Luther, selected writings (see “Additional Bibliography” on p. 4, below)

 

 

Exams and Written Assignments:

 

            Mid-course short-answer exam in class on April 28, at 4:10 p.m., on your understanding of Gustaf Wingren, Luther on Vocation.  Students must pass this exam to pass the course.  Those who do not pass it the first time will need to take it again.

 

            Final paper of 8-10 pages (longer for post-M.A./M.Div. students) based on some aspect of the idea of vocation as it relates to ethics.  This should involve use of the course readings on vocation as well as other knowledge you have of theological ethics.  This is not intended to be primarily a research paper but rather an informed discussion of your approach to and understanding of the topic(s) in question.  This paper is due on Tuesday, May 13, at 10:00 a.m.  This date is the morning following the last day of class on Monday, May 12.   Receiving your paper earlier would be helpful, especially if you are a graduating senior.

 

 

 

Class Schedule and Assignments

 

 

April 7             Introduction to the course and the topic.  Read in preparation for class: The Christian’s Calling in the World, by Marc Kolden

 

 

April 14           Read ahead of time Gustaf Wingren, Luther on Vocation, pp. 1-77.  Be prepared to discuss it by bringing written comments, questions, and criticisms.  This is slow reading, so give yourself time.  Try to figure out the meanings of key terms and concepts, and try to see how the whole chapter is organized.  Be sure to notice that the title of this section, “Earth and Heaven,” is not spatial but eschatological.

 

 

April 21           Read Wingren, Luther on Vocation, pp. 78-161.  Note how Wingren (Luther) thinks about God ruling in the present age, in which God struggles with sin, death, and the devil over persons and offices.  Notice what he says about prayer and about humans as God’s co-workers.  Be alert to how the distinctions from the previous chapter continue to function in this one.

                                    Also, by this time you should have chosen a paper topic; this should be reported to the instructor in written form during class.  

 

 

April 28           Read Wingren, Luther on Vocation, pp. 162-251.  This final chapter looks at the individual Christian person in light of the first two chapters—as righteous and sinful simultaneously and as involving the death of the sinful self precisely in one’s callings. 

                     At 4:10, Exam on Wingren, Luther on Vocation

 

 

May 5             Read Douglas Schuurman, Vocation, pp. 1-90 and come to class with specific

                        comments and questions for class discussion.

 

 

May 12           Final class session—the only assignment is to be working on your final paper. 

The instructor will make presentations for discussion on some of the following: (1) criticisms of the idea of vocation from feminist and liberation perspectives, (2) relating vocation to mission, (3) bearing one’s cross, and (4) vocation as it relates to other approaches to Christian ethics.

 

 

Prof. Kolden’s office is Gullixson Hall 303; phone 641-3217 (or ext. 217).  He is usually on campus Monday through Friday, although he is in classes or meetings each week on Tuesdays and Wednesdays from 2:00 to 5:00 p.m. and has classes on Thursdays at 10:40 and 11:40 a.m. and at 4:10 p.m.

 

 

NOTE: Since this is a six-week course it is very important that you begin work immediately and not fall behind.  There is reading assigned for most class periods, including the first one! The reading should be done prior to class so that discussion will be based on knowing the reading and will be able to involve all persons present.  It is important that the course assignments be completed on schedule.  No Incompletes will be allowed except in those cases where the instructor asks that some work be re-done or in cases where a student has a major emergency.

 

 

Additional Bibliography: by Martin Luther on vocation and ethics

 

Unless otherwise note, all are in the American Edition of Luther’s Works (the red volumes; abbreviated as “LW”); copies are in the Library reference room and the stacks; some are also in Timothy Lull, ed., Martin Luther’s Basic Theological Writings.

 

 

LW, Vol. 44

“The Judgment of Martin Luther on Monastic Vows”

“To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation”

 

 

LW, Vol. 45

“Exhortation to the Knights . . .”

“To the Councilman of All Cities . . .”    (also in Lull)

“On Temporal Authority”                                  (also in Lull)

“The Estate of Marriage”

“A Sermon on the Estate of Marriage”

“Ordinance on the Common Chest”

“Trade and Usury”

 

 

LW, Vol. 46

“Whether Soldiers, Too, Can be Saved”

“A Sermon on Keeping the Children in School”

 

 

Also

“The Large Catechism”  (sections on the Commandments and the First Article of the Creed)

Index references in “Lectures on Genesis,” LW, vols. 1ff.

Index references in “Lectures on Galatians,” LW, vols. 26-27a

Index references in the “Index Volume,” LW, vol. 55

            plus

Selections in Plass, ed., What Luther Says  (e.g., no. 4251)

A sermon on John 21:19-24 in the Lenker edition of Luther, vol. 10, pp. 241ff.